Comparing the BMW i5 and BMW 5 Series

The BMW 5 Series has been a benchmark in the luxury sedan segment for some time, known for its blend of performance, technology, and comfort. With the introduction of the BMW i5, BMW is pushed the envelope even further by bringing electric power to this iconic model. Here, we will compare the traditional BMW 5 Series with the new BMW i5, highlighting their key differences, performance metrics, technological advancements, and overall driving experience.

1. Powertrain and Performance

BMW 5 Series

The BMW 5 Series offers a range of powertrains, including inline-4, inline-6, and V8 engines, many of which are equipped with BMW’s TwinPower Turbo technology. The power output ranges from 248 horsepower in the base 530i to 523 horsepower in the M550i xDrive.

The 5 Series is known for its balanced handling, responsive steering, and smooth ride quality. Additionally, the 5 Series offers a plug-in hybrid variant, the 530e, which combines a 2.0-liter turbocharged engine with an electric motor, delivering a combined output of 288 horsepower and an electric-only range of around 21 miles.

BMW i5

The BMW i5 is an all-electric version of the 5 Series, part of BMW’s expanding i line of electric vehicles. The i5 is powered by BMW’s latest electric powertrain technology, with power outputs expected to range from 335 horsepower to over 500 horsepower in performance-oriented versions. The i5 promises brisk acceleration, with the high-performance variants potentially matching or exceeding the acceleration of the M550i. One of the key advantages of the i5 is its smooth and instantaneous torque delivery, characteristic of electric vehicles, providing a seamless and exhilarating driving experience.

2. Design and Aesthetics

Exterior

Both the BMW 5 Series and the i5 share a similar design language, emphasizing a sleek, dynamic, and elegant appearance. The i5, however, features some unique design elements to distinguish it from its internal combustion counterpart. These include a more aerodynamic front fascia, a closed kidney grille (as it doesn’t require the same cooling as a combustion engine), and blue accents that signify its electric nature. Both models maintain BMW’s signature proportions, with a long hood, short overhangs, and a flowing roofline.

Interior

Inside, both the 5 Series and i5 offer a luxurious and tech-forward cabin. High-quality materials, meticulous craftsmanship, and advanced technology are standard in both models. The i5 may feature additional eco-friendly materials and unique design touches that emphasize its electric nature. Both cars offer spacious interiors with comfortable seating for five, but the i5’s floor may be slightly higher due to the battery placement, potentially affecting rear-seat foot space.

3. Technology and Features

BMW 5 Series

The 5 Series is equipped with the latest in BMW’s iDrive infotainment system, featuring a large touchscreen display, voice control, and gesture control. It includes a comprehensive suite of driver assistance features, such as adaptive cruise control, lane-keeping assist, blind-spot monitoring, and automated parking. The 5 Series also offers advanced connectivity options, including wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto, a Wi-Fi hotspot, and multiple USB ports.

BMW i5

The BMW i5 takes technology to the next level with an enhanced version of the iDrive system, potentially incorporating a larger curved display that integrates both the instrument cluster and infotainment system into a s

ingle, seamless unit. The i5 is expected to offer even more advanced driver assistance features, including enhanced autonomous driving capabilities. Additionally, the i5 will feature the latest in connectivity and infotainment, catering to the needs of modern, tech-savvy drivers.

4. Range and Charging

BMW 5 Series

The plug-in hybrid 530e variant offers an electric-only range of approximately 21 miles, after which the gasoline engine takes over. Charging can be done at home using a standard outlet or faster using a Level 2 charger. The conventional gasoline models do not require charging but come with the convenience of quick refueling.

BMW i5

The BMW i5, being an all-electric vehicle, offers a significantly larger electric range compared to the plug-in hybrid 530e. Depending on the variant and battery pack, the i5’s range is expected to exceed 300 miles on a single charge. The i5  supports fast charging, allowing for a substantial charge in a short amount of time, making it convenient for long-distance travel. BMW’s expanding network of public charging stations and home charging solutions ensure that i5 owners will have access to efficient and reliable charging options.

5. Driving Experience

BMW 5 Series

The 5 Series is celebrated for its dynamic driving experience, balancing sporty handling with a comfortable ride. The various engine options provide a range of performance levels to suit different driving preferences. The adaptive suspension system enhances ride comfort and handling, making the 5 Series a versatile vehicle for both spirited driving and long-distance cruising.

BMW i5

The i5 promises a distinctive driving experience characterized by the immediate torque delivery and silent operation of an electric vehicle. The low center of gravity, due to the battery placement, enhances handling and stability. The i5’s regenerative braking system adds another layer of engagement, allowing drivers to recapture energy while slowing down. Performance-oriented versions of the i5 are expected to offer exhilarating acceleration, rivaling traditional high-performance models.

6. Environmental Impact

BMW 5 Series

While the plug-in hybrid 530e offers reduced emissions and improved fuel efficiency, the traditional gasoline-powered 5 Series models still produce significant emissions. BMW has made strides in improving the efficiency of their engines, but the environmental impact of combustion engines remains a concern.

BMW i5

The BMW i5 represents a significant step towards reducing environmental impact, with zero tailpipe emissions and the use of renewable energy sources for charging. The i5’s production process also emphasizes sustainability, with increased use of recycled and eco-friendly materials. As electric vehicles continue to grow in popularity, the i5 contributes to BMW’s broader efforts to reduce the carbon footprint of their vehicle lineup.

Conclusion

Both the BMW 5 Series and the BMW i5 represent the pinnacle of BMW’s engineering and design prowess. The 5 Series offers a range of traditional and hybrid powertrains, providing flexibility for different driving needs and preferences. The i5, on the other hand, signifies BMW’s commitment to an electric future, offering cutting-edge technology, impressive performance, and environmental benefits.

Choosing between the two will depend on your priorities. If you value the familiarity of gasoline engines and the convenience of quick refueling, the BMW 5 Series remains an excellent choice. However, if you are ready to embrace the future of mobility with zero emissions and advanced electric power, the BMW i5 offers an exciting and forward-thinking alternative. Regardless of your choice, both models embody BMW’s commitment to luxury, performance, and innovation.